That cut looks thick and very well-done, so I’ll give you two options:
Option 1: How to cook a thick steak properly (juicy, not gray)
Best for ribeye, filet, NY strip, sirloin.
Ingredients
-
1 thick steak (1½–2 inches)
-
Salt (kosher if you have it)
-
Black pepper
-
1–2 tbsp oil (avocado or canola)
-
2 tbsp butter
-
2 garlic cloves, smashed
-
Fresh rosemary or thyme (optional)
Method (Pan + Oven = foolproof)
-
Salt early
Salt both sides generously. Let sit 30–60 min (or overnight in the fridge). -
Preheat
Oven to 400°F / 205°C.
Heat a cast-iron skillet until very hot. -
Sear
Add oil. Sear steak 2–3 min per side until deeply brown. -
Baste
Add butter, garlic, herbs. Tilt pan, spoon butter over steak for ~30 seconds. -
Finish in oven
Transfer skillet to oven:-
Medium-rare: pull at 125–130°F
-
Medium: 135–140°F
-
-
Rest
Rest 10 minutes. Do not skip this.
👉 Result: browned outside, pink and juicy inside (the opposite of the picture 😅)
Option 2: If your steak already looks like that (salvage mode)
Turn it into something delicious instead of chewing sadness.
Steak & Onion Gravy
-
Slice steak very thin across the grain.
-
Sauté sliced onions in butter until golden.
-
Add garlic, then:
-
1 cup beef broth
-
Splash of Worcestershire
-
-
Simmer 10–15 min.
-
Add steak slices just to warm through.
Serve over:
-
Mashed potatoes
-
Rice
-
Toast (open-faced sandwich)
🔥 Shockingly good.
If you want, tell me what cut you’re actually working with and how you like it cooked—I’ll dial it in exactly.